130 Comments

I think there are some in this country who call themselves patriots, some of whom incited an insurrection to interfere with a valid election, who need to look at these people and listen to them. In spite of all the hell they have been through they are true patriots.

Expand full comment

Juxtaposition of sorts....just before reading this I read an article that the WaPo reported about consumers spending less on Christmas and the story focused on a jewelry store in a large city and the owner was bemoaning that last year people spend literally thousands of dollars on items like tennis bracelets and this year they are buying gifts more in the hundreds of dollars range. And then I read this where to hardships of the folks in Ukraine are in desperate need of basics like water and food. I know Americans can be generous, but to me this is so offensive and speaks volumes about our nation today....the WaPo feels it is more important to run a story about how a high end store is doing maybe because of inflation than to say run an op ed that says "Hey folks, what is wrong with this picture, who are we, a bunch of spoiled brats who are sad because we can't afford a $2,000 tennis bracelet or are we a people that say let's forego the useless Christmas presents this year and send help to the freedom loving Ukrainians (or put in another people...lets say the Native Americans)". I have to say I much prefer a Reason to Smile than a story about how "inflation may steal Christmas" and the equating Christmas with how many presents we can buy.

Expand full comment

Thank you Dan and Elliot.

It is good to be reminded that the human spirit is in indomitable, strong-brave-impossible to defeat, even in the midst of the incredible horrors of a Russian invasion. I may have to re-read "Man's Search for Meaning." Sometimes the joy that surprises is born from cruelty and injustice.

Expand full comment

My goodness, what rock have you been hiding under? Do you find it confusing that the president of the Ukraine is, in your statement, being labeled a Neo-Nazi - and he’s Jewish? And who gave the Russian Federation the right to attack another nation for being (in your words) Neo-Nazi’s? Which country is indiscriminately killing non-combatants? Which country has committed war crimes in the others country? The Ukrainians are freedom loving people who want to decide their future for themselves. The Russians on the other hand are controlled by a despot who thinks nothing of killing innocent men, women, and children to fulfill his vision of a glorious Russian Empire! He’s on a fools errand and will hopefully be deposed by the Russian people.

Expand full comment

My facts straight 300 historians signed papers saying to the best of their knowledge and looking back that ukrainens being neo natzi is propaganda and a lie. So who should I believe .You. Zelinsky is Jewish .Stop watching false news .

Expand full comment
founding

Mr. Rather and Mr. Kirschner - Why do you allow trolls like “Marek” onto your forum?

Expand full comment

Good news; of a sort. For me, a candle in the dark. At 74 and a Vietnam veteran, my comfortable feeling of being American has been torn down and lies in shreds about me. I do what I can within my reach and capabilities; but, it seems too little too late. I guess I am lucky that I can choose to shorten my view of Life to my immediate surroundings. :(

Expand full comment

Marshata --that was the most powerful, accurate, eloquent, beautiful statement I’ve ever heard or read of the assessment of black people in this country. You have spoken the truth. November is also Native American Month and look what this country did and still doing to Native Americans! I want you to know that you have spoken the sad but true America. Sometimes the hypocrisy of this country is overwhelming. I say to every young American go abroad and see other countries and when you return, if you do, make this a better country for everyone, every color and give due reward to the people like you said that built this starting with the White House, built by slaves. This country will never own up until it admits the original sin of slavery. Period! Thank you again for your beautiful statement which I’m going to keep and reread again and again.

Expand full comment

Wonderful write up and inspiring video. As Americans we are digesting the announcement of a past president that wants to run again for the highest office in our country, some would say the world because of the respect and influence America has on the world stage. Trump will make the history books and history will not be as kind to his legacy as the Republican party. He will be remembered for fabricating a lie about our election process, an alleged organizer of the insurrection on January 6, 2021 ( I say alleged, only because I value our judicial process and a person is assumed innocence until proven guilty)and the first President to not partake in a peaceful transfer of power. He literally sh** on our traditions of Democracy that we should all hold sacred. Yet there he stood to announce his campaign for 2024. Hopefully we can look past the ageism that we have in America and elect based on who will hold our democracy together and uphold our traditions. I am proud that people used democracy to send a message in the midterm elections that integrity and freedom matter over all else. We have to start looking past party and put protecting our democracy above all else. I am appreciative to Mr. Dan Rather for his writings. Real journalism is so important today. The service that he does along with the service of Heather Cox Richardson is invaluable in this world of entertainment news. I grew up watching Dan Rather on the nightly news and I have shared his posts with my Fox News watching parents and I hope his messages will help them see the truth.

Expand full comment

This is so encouraging! Thank you for sharing it: getting to see people experiencing freedom again! Such joy in the midst of suffering. Supporting Ukraine continues to be a world priority, and continuing the war is causing the Russians dearly.

Expand full comment

It is not the question of Kherson, but why did that brain-dead, insane Biden the brute push ruthless NATO aka rabid dogs into Russia's backyard (Ukraine)? All these wars and mayhem could have been avoided, right?

Expand full comment

I worry about the Ukraine people and how they are suffering every day and it upset me that they can't stop Russia!!! I keep hoping they will be allowed in NATO and that NATO will go in and help the push Russia back and help Ukraine with their power grid and so they can start rebuilding . Now winter is here these poor people will suffer more so they need to get the people out of Ukraine and some where they can live and go on with their lives!! Arrest Putin and put him on trial for war crimes!!

Expand full comment

Thank you for this beautiful commentary on the strength, resilience, and courage of the Ukrainian people.

Expand full comment

Dan, Thank you so much for reminding us all how very, very dear freedom can be.

Expand full comment

Let's all never forget who the invaders are. Realize, if Russia stops fighting there will be peace. If Ukraine stops fighting there will be wholesale slaughter and genocide. So, let's not pressure Ukraine to negotiate a peace deal.

Expand full comment

This shows democracy is always worth fighting for.

Expand full comment