Steady

Share this post

Unspeakable Horror

steady.substack.com

Unspeakable Horror

The scenes from Ukraine

Dan Rather
and
Elliot Kirschner
Apr 5, 2022
446
313
Share this post

Unspeakable Horror

steady.substack.com
Volunteers carry dead bodies from a basement to take to a morgue on April 4, 2022, in Bucha, Ukraine. (Photo by Anastasia Vlasova/Getty Images)

The pictures from Ukraine tell a story of unspeakable horror. They are echoed by the narratives of those who lived through it — and can be measured in the bloodshed of those who did not. 

These images of murdered civilians, of mass graves, of once-thriving cities reduced to rubble, seem transported from another time or dimension.

But these are not colorized newsreels from World War II. Nor is this some Hollywood movie, no matter how much we would give for it to be fiction. 

Modern technology, like smartphone cameras, drones, and satellites, means this war is being broadcast in ways previous battlefields were not.

Twitter avatar for @ABC
ABC News @ABC
DEVASTATION: Drone footage shows how the landscape of Ukraine's port city of Mariupol has been transformed into a nightmarish scene, with residential building battered and blackened after weeks of Russian bombardment. abcn.ws/3x0tViM
9:50 PM ∙ Apr 4, 2022
329Likes185Retweets

When I was in Vietnam, for example, we were still shooting on film, a precious resource measured by the foot. It usually took days for what we saw on the battlefield to make it to the public. Now hard drives can hold almost unlimited amounts of information, and social media platforms enable nearly anyone to go live. 

Putin can lie all he wants. And it is a sure bet he will do so. This is the currency in which he has always trafficked. But the world has put a spotlight on his murderous mendacity. 

Twitter avatar for @nytimes
The New York Times @nytimes
Satellite images show bodies lay in Bucha for weeks, despite Russian claims
nyti.msSatellite images show bodies lay in Bucha for weeks, despite Russian claimsAn analysis of satellite images by The New York Times rebuts claims by Russia that the killing of civilians in Bucha, a suburb of Kyiv, occurred after its soldiers had left the town.
8:34 PM ∙ Apr 4, 2022
1,870Likes865Retweets

We weep...

We pray...

We feel a deep tear at the fabric of our common humanity...

But we know that these feelings are far from a sufficient response to such bloody injustice. There are specific definitions for “war crimes” and “genocide.” I will leave it to others to place what Russian forces are doing in Ukraine in those categories, but on a gut level we know what we are seeing.

The bodies in the streets…

Gunshots to the back of heads…

Hands tied behind the back…

Civilians. Fathers. Mothers. Children. This is the face of evil.

Twitter avatar for @washingtonpost
The Washington Post @washingtonpost
Video posted to social media Saturday and verified by The Post showed at least nine people including one child laying in the street of a residential area in Bucha, north of Kyiv, after Russian forces retreated from the area. They appear to be dead.
wapo.stBodies, rubble line the streets of Bucha following Russian retreat
10:09 PM ∙ Apr 2, 2022
816Likes474Retweets

Sadly, in war, noncombatants often die. And we must acknowledge these losses occur when the United States is fighting, as well. The death of innocent civilians is a major reason all war is hell. But this is something else. Russia is the instigator, the originator, and the aggressor. It invaded Ukraine. And as the Russian military gets outmaneuvered and outsmarted, it retreats — leaving deliberate terror and death in its wake.

The world is receiving an unwanted lesson in what unchecked autocracy can unleash. We vowed “never again.” Sadly, there have been many “agains.” Most have occurred in places outside of the global media’s focus. But if anything good can come from this calamity, it can be a commitment to fighting back against such naked aggression.

While the rest of the world reacts, it is the Ukrainains who bear by far the heaviest cost. They are not only fighting for their own survival but also serving as the frontline defense of a much broader world order.

As the days have turned into weeks, the carnage on our screens continues to intensify. It is so unsettling (in a world where so much of the news is perilous) that we may feel tempted to look away. We risk becoming inured to the death and suffering. It is horror on repeat. But we cannot afford to hide from the full force of the truth. We cannot accept this as fate beyond our control.

There is a fight for the future of this world between democracy and autocracy. It takes many shapes and is playing out on many stages — including here in the U.S. What the Ukrainians have demonstrated is that we must engage in this battle, in any way we can. These are the times in which we live. We have no choice in that matter. But for all the heartbreak, we should also realize that a better world can emerge.

That’s why I wanted to leave you tonight with an example of encouragement. The world-famous chef José Andrés has dedicated his life recently to feeding those in need in the wake of natural or man-made disasters through his nonprofit charity World Central Kitchen. Now he is rushing into these godforsaken towns where the Russian army committed its atrocities.

Twitter avatar for @chefjoseandres
José Andrés @chefjoseandres
On our way to Bucha & Irpin again! We @WCKitchen have 2 trucks filled with 5,000 kilos of food…plus 600 hot meals from a WCK restaurant in Kyiv. We are meeting the Mayor to escort us & make sure everyone is safe…There is huge food need & curfew starts soon! #ChefsForUkraine 🇺🇦
4:36 PM ∙ Apr 2, 2022
31,855Likes5,747Retweets

In a world full of hunger, let us all try to offer the nourishment of empathy and the sustenance of hope.

Leave a comment

Share

313
Share this post

Unspeakable Horror

steady.substack.com
313 Comments
Alicia Peterson
Writes Alicia’s Newsletter
Apr 23, 2022

I’m become “numb” to what’s happening. I’m spending less time listening to world news. I’m suffering from anxiety & loneliness. I’m very concerned about the future, losing our freedom our ancestors fought for against the Britain. I see history repeating itself. I’m afraid for the children and our adult children. I pray for God to remove all the evil going on. I can’t handle life anymore. I’m almost 71 yrs young.

Expand full comment
ReplyCollapse
1 reply
Karen B
Apr 15, 2022

What is happening in Ukraine must be stopped. It's not only horrific, it shows the worst side of humanity. Putin must be removed from power. We must show the Russian people what their "leader"is doing. Whether you want to live in an autocracy or just don't know any better, their leader should never be so brutal. Taking out his opposition, bombing Syria to oblivion or trying to flatten Mariopul, he has shown himself to be a worthless, cruel and selfish man inspired by nothing but his own aggradisement.

Expand full comment
ReplyCollapse
311 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Dan Rather
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing